PrivilegeScribe · Requirements Discovery

Law Firm Questionnaire

Practical use cases for source-enriched and noise-enriched legal AI prompts
Prepared for: Date: Matter / Ref:

Purpose. Before building the next version of PrivilegeScribe, I want to base it on real firm workflows rather than assumptions. This questionnaire maps the practical use cases that would matter in day-to-day legal work — what arrives, what gets produced, and what would actually save time.

How to complete it. Most questions are tick-boxes. Answer what you can, skip anything that does not apply. Estimated time: 15–20 minutes. There are no wrong answers; even "we do not do this" is useful information.

Confidentiality. This form contains no client data. Please do not include client names or matter specifics. General descriptions are sufficient.

A Firm and Practice Profile
A1. How would you describe the firm?
A2. Which practice areas are most active?
Tick all that apply.
A3. Approximately how many matters is the firm handling at any one time?
A4. Roughly what share of a lawyer's week goes to:
Document work %
Client contact %
Court / negotiation %
Other %
A5. What is the firm's appetite for new internal tools?
A6. Is there an IT or knowledge-management person who would evaluate a tool, or is it the lawyers themselves?
B Input Sources the Firm Actually Receives What arrives in a matter file
B1. Which of the following does the firm routinely receive or produce?
Tick all that apply.
B2. Which of these are currently a pain point — slow, expensive, or error-prone?
Rank 1 = biggest pain. Leave blank if not applicable.
Item Rank Item Rank
Client meeting notes Scanned documents
Dictation and transcription Email review
Phone call records Contract review
WhatsApp evidence Court transcript summaries
Due diligence folders Other:
B3. How is transcription currently handled?
B4. If an external service is used, is client consent obtained before sending material?
B5. How often is the input material in a language other than the firm's working language?
Which language combinations?
B6. How would you rate the audio quality of the material the firm typically receives?
B7. Does the firm ever need to work from material where the speaker is unidentified or the transcript has gaps?
C Documents the Firm Actually Produces What gets filed
C1. Which of the following does the firm produce regularly?
Tick all that apply, and circle or star the ones that are most time-consuming.
C2. For the two or three most frequent of these, roughly how long does each take today?
Document Time (hours / minutes)
C3. Who produces them?
C4. What is the target quality level?
C5. Which documents must carry a specific format (house style, court format, client format)?
C6. Are there documents that must not be generated by a tool, even with review?
C7. Is there a standard template library the firm uses?
D Where in the Workflow the Tool Would Sit
D1. At what point in a matter would a tool like this be most useful?
D2. Who would use the tool day to day?
D3. Would the tool be used on a single matter at a time, or across several matters in parallel?
D4. Where would the tool run?
D5. What is the firm's current policy on software that processes client material?
D6. Is there a minimum output quality below which a lawyer would not use the tool?
E Confidentiality, Privilege, and Regulatory Boundaries Most important section
E1. Would the firm be comfortable using an offline tool where no client data leaves the machine?
E2. Would the firm ever want the tool to not process certain categories of material?
E3. Does the firm need every output to carry a privilege and confidentiality banner?
E4. Does the firm need an audit trail showing what was processed, when, and by which prompt?
E5. In the firm's view, what would make a tool like this fail a professional-responsibility test?
E6. Are there jurisdictions or regulators whose rules would apply?
E7. Does the firm work with any client whose contract restricts the use of AI or automated tools?
F Quality, Review, and Liability
F1. For each type of output, what level of human review would the firm require?
Output type None Light Full
Internal draft
Client-facing
Court-facing
Filing
F2. Would the firm want the tool to show its sources for every statement it produces?
F3. Would the firm want the tool to never invent facts, and to say "not documented" when the source is silent?
F4. Would the firm want the tool to flag contradictions between sources?
F5. If a tool-generated draft contained an error, where would the firm place responsibility?
F6. Would the firm require the tool to be certified, insured, or contracted in a particular way before use?
G Languages and Jurisdictions
G1. What are the firm's working languages?
G2. What language combinations arise most often in incoming material?
G3. Does the firm need translation integrated into the workflow, or is translation handled separately?
G4. For Swiss work, does the firm need to distinguish legal German (Swiss usage) from German (Germany)?
G5. Does the firm work across cantonal or national borders in a way that affects document format?
H Commercial Value and Priorities
H1. If the tool saved time on the documents you identified in Section C, roughly how much time per matter would justify adopting it?
H2. Which of these would be the strongest argument for adopting the tool?
Rank 1–5, 1 = strongest.
Argument Rank
Saves lawyer time
Saves assistant time
Improves consistency across matters
Improves confidentiality compared to cloud tools
Enables work the firm currently cannot take on
Creates an audit trail
Other:
H3. How would the firm prefer to pay?
H4. Would the firm want to test it on a real matter first, with the client's consent?
H5. If the tool worked as described, would the firm be willing to be named as a reference or pilot partner?
H6. Is there anyone else in the firm — or in your network — who should see this questionnaire?
I Open Questions Most valuable section
I1. What is the single document or task you would most like to see automated, even if nothing else is?
I2. What is the single thing that, if a tool got it wrong, would make you never use it again?
I3. Is there a use case you have been asked for by a client — or that you have declined because it was too slow — that a tool like this could unlock?
I4. Anything else you would want the developer to know before building?
Thank you. Once returned, I will use the answers to prioritise which prompts and workflows to build first, and to make sure the confidentiality and privilege boundaries of the tool align with the firm's actual expectations.
Completed by:
Role:
Date returned: